Article: The Athlete and the Sport Medicine Doctor

The Athlete and the Sport Medicine Doctor

Wade Elliott, MD, FRCP(SEM), Dip Sport Med 

Dr. Wade Elliott is a Sport & Exercise Medicine physician and Assistant Clinical Professor at McMaster University. He works with athletes across the lifespan and writes about the intersection of sport, health, injury and recovery. 

Substack: https://thesemnotebook.substack.com/

Instagram: dr_wade_elliott

This article uses a composite clinical story. Details have been altered or combined to protect patient privacy. 

Injury prevention allows for continuous enjoyment of sport. By working closely with their sport medicine doctor, athletes can remain injury-free, support their long-term health, and continue to excel at their sport in a more sustained way.  

A sport medicine doctor received a call about one of their cross-country athletes.  

They were in hospital with a tibia fracture. 

When the doctor spoke to her, her first words were: “I probably should have mentioned this sooner…” 

Significant fractures are not common in runners. Could this one have been prevented?  

Backtrack six weeks ago. She had completed a preseason physical. Nothing concerning was reported and no obvious red flags were identified. 

What the doctor didn’t know was that she had already been experiencing localized shin pain for several weeks, and it was beginning to affect her running. She had also been eating less and losing weight, believing it might help her run faster. She knew something wasn’t quite right. But she also worried that saying something might mean being told to stop training or competing. 

So, when the questions were asked, she said she was “fine.” 

Several weeks later, she wasn’t. 

Earlier disclosure about her shin pain, reduced food intake and weight loss would have raised concern for a possible bone stress injury and low energy availability and prompted further assessment. Whether that would have prevented the eventual fracture is impossible to know. But it might have changed what happened next. 

The role of sport medicine physician isn’t just about treating injuries after they’ve happened. It’s also about recognizing overall health concerns and risk factors early enough to change what might happen next.  

That’s a space where trust and communication between an athlete and their sports doctor thrive and are most effective.   

The Athlete’s Perspective 

Athletes want to run. Or play. They want to compete. Their main mission is to train as best they can, so their performance is at the highest level it can be.  That drive comes with a host of emotions. Excitement, anticipation, dedication. But also fear. Fear they might not perform as well as they could.  

When warning signs show up around a possible medical issue, a different type of fear can creep in that can take on an entirely different level of concern.  

What if this is something serious and the doctor says I’m not able to run?  

What if this changes my season or my future in sport? 

“It’s probably nothing and if I just modify my training a bit, it should be fine…I think I’ll be okay” 

When an athlete like the one in our story, starts to feel symptoms they know are impacting their training, fear can start to ramp up.   

 Most athletes are highly driven. They reached the level they are at partly by learning to push through discomfort. Training hurts. Competing hurts. Distinguishing between “this is just hard” and “something is wrong” is a skill in itself, and even good athletes get it wrong sometimes, in both directions. 

 So, when a new pain arrives that isn’t going away and feels different than usual pain, it opens an internal decision-making process about how to proceed. 

Sometimes that’s straightforward. Sometimes not.  

The Team Physician Perspective  

The sport doctor has a different perspective and responsibility. To prioritize athlete health even when it creates a difficult conversation about training, competition or a future in that sport.    

Those are never easy discussions. But it’s rarely the end of the story.  

Some symptoms are truly minor and not concerning. Others, carry significant risks and consequences. The sports medicine doctor’s role is to advocate for the athlete when there are real concerns. And to voice the things an athlete may not want to hear. But are crucial. 

That role evolves further to guiding the next steps. Treatment, training modifications and mapping out return to activity. 

In the case at the start of this story, could the outcome have been different?  

Possibly. At the very least, early disclosure from the athlete might have changed the path that followed. But perhaps the more important question isn’t why she didn’t tell the doctor about her shin pain or other symptoms when asked. It’s what was missing in the relationship between the athlete and doctor for her to feel comfortable mentioning it at the start of the season.  

The sports doctor needs the athlete to trust them with all the relevant information to make good medical decisions. And the athlete needs to trust what the physician will do with the information once they do. 

What should an athlete take away from this?  

You don’t need to decide whether a symptom is serious before mentioning it. That’s part of the reason the sports medicine doctor is there. 

New, persistent or worsening pain, or any unexplained symptoms are worth discussing.  As are any unexpected changes in performance or recovery or if something is just feeling off.  

Asking for help doesn’t necessarily mean being told to stop. 

That conversation works best when both athlete and physician have the same information. 

Sometimes the safest plan does require stepping away from sport. But often the conversation is about what can be modified, what can continue safely, what needs investigation and how to keep moving toward a return to full training.

Subscribe to the PlaySafe Newsletter to stay connected and receive news and updates.

Group of people